[1]卢旺达,王 春,代 文,等.无人机地形建模误差空间分布影响因素研究[J].南京师大学报(自然科学版),2023,46(02):44-53.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1001-4616.2023.02.006]
　Lu Wangda,Wang Chun,Dai Wen,et al.Study on the Influencing Factors of Spatial Distribution of Errors in UAV-Based Terrain Modeling[J].Journal of Nanjing Normal University(Natural Science Edition),2023,46(02):44-53.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1001-4616.2023.02.006]
点击复制

无人机地形建模误差空间分布影响因素研究()
分享到：

《南京师大学报（自然科学版）》[ISSN:1001-4616/CN:32-1239/N]

卷:
第46卷
期数:
2023年02期
页码:
44-53
栏目:
地理学
出版日期:
2023-06-15

文章信息/Info

Title:
Study on the Influencing Factors of Spatial Distribution of Errors in UAV-Based Terrain Modeling
文章编号:
1001-4616(2023)02-0044-10
作者:
卢旺达1; 2; 王 春2; 3; 代 文1; 4; 钱 伟1; 李 敏3; 位 宏5; 杨 昕5
(1.南京信息工程大学遥感与测绘工程学院,江苏 南京 211800)
(2.实景地理环境安徽省重点实验室,安徽 滁州 239000)
(3.滁州学院地理信息与旅游学院,安徽 滁州 239000)
(4.南京信息工程大学地理科学学院,江苏 南京 211800)
(5.南京师范大学地理科学学院,江苏 南京 210023)
Author(s):
Lu Wangda1; 2; Wang Chun2; 3; Dai Wen1; 4; Qian Wei1; Li Min3; Wei Hong5; Yang Xin5
(1.School of Remote Sensing and Geomatics Engineering,Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology,Nanjing211800,China)
(2.Anhui Province Key Laboratory of Physical Geographical Environment,Chuzhou239000,China)
(3.School of Geographic Information and Tourism,Chuzhou University,Chuzhou239000,China)
(4.School of Geographical Sciences,Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology,Nanjing211800,China)
(5.School of Geography,Nanjing Normal University......)
关键词:
消费级无人机; 地形建模; 图像采集策略; 误差空间分布; 控制点数量
Keywords:
consumer UAV;  terrain modeling;  image collection strategies;  spatial distribution of errors;  GCPs
分类号:
P231
DOI:
10.3969/j.issn.1001-4616.2023.02.006
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
无人机发展迅速,已经在地球科学领域得到了广泛应用. 前人以中误差(root mean square error,RMSE)为精度评价指标对影响无人机摄影测量精度的各类因素进行了大量研究. 但是,基于无人机摄影测量的地形建模误差往往空间上变化分布,中误差无法反映误差的空间分布特征. 因此,本文从误差空间分布的视角出发,通过计算误差空间分布图、误差的莫兰指数、样区整体的平均误差和标准误差,分析了相机倾角、航高和控制点数量对地形建模高程误差的大小及空间分布的影响. 在黄土高原两个小流域的实验结果表明:(1)在无控制测量的情况下,误差受相机倾角的影响较大,采用较大角度的倾斜摄影不仅可以降低整体误差,还能改善误差的空间分布,减少误差的空间自相关性.(2)航高方面,尽管航高(60～160 m)变高会增大误差,但是航高对误差的空间分布影响不大.(3)在有控制测量的情况下,控制点的使用不仅降低了整体误差也优化了误差空间分布. 在整体误差方面,使用少量的控制点即能达到一个稳定的精度水平. 但此时,误差的空间分布还可以继续优化,要使样区的误差空间分布达到稳定的水平,需要相对较多的控制点. 本研究为使用消费级无人机进行地形建模提供了有益的参考,在实际应用中可根据本文的结论优化航线设计方案和控制点布设.
Abstract:
With the rapid development of UAVs, it has been widely used in the field of geoscience. A large number of previous studies have analyzed the various factors that affect the accuracy of UAV photogrammetry with RMSE as the accuracy evaluation index. However, terrain modeling errors based on UAV photogrammetry are often distributed in space, and RMSE cannot reflect the spatial distribution characteristics of errors. Thus, from the perspective of the spatial distribution of errors, this paper analyzes the influence of camera angle, flight height and the number of ground control points on the elevation error and spatial distribution of terrain modeling by calculating spatial distribution of errors, Moran's Index of error, mean error and standard deviation error. Two small watershed areas on the Loess Plateau are selected as the study area. The experimental results show that:(1)Without ground control points, the error is greatly affect by the camera angle. Using higher oblique camera angles(higher than 10°)can not only reduce the overall error, but also improve the spatial distribution of errors and reduce the spatial autocorrelation of the error.(2)In the terms of flight height, although the increase of flight height(60-160 m)will increase the error, flight height has little effect on the spatial distribution of errors.(3)When there are GCPs, the use of GCPs reduces the overall error and optimizes the spatial distribution of errors. In the terms of overall error, a stable accuracy level can be achieved by using only a small number of GCPs. However, at this time, the spatial distribution of errors can continue to be optimized. More GCPs are required to make the spatial distribution of errors reach a stable level. This study provides a useful reference for terrain modeling using consumer UAV. In practical application, the measurement scheme and control points layout can be optimized according to the conclusions of this paper.

参考文献/References:

[1]李德仁,李明. 无人机遥感系统的研究进展与应用前景[J]. 武汉大学学报(信息科学版),2014,39(5):505-513.
[2]SHAHBAZI M,MENARD P,SOHN G,et al. Unmanned aerial image dataset:ready for 3D reconstruction[J]. Data in brief,2019,25:103962.
[3]CANDIAGO S,REMONDINO F,DE GIGLIO M,et al. Evaluating multispectral images and vegetation indices for precision farming applications from UAV images[J]. Remote sensing,2015,7(4):4026-4047.
[4]LAPORTE-FAURET Q,MARIEU V,CASTELLE B,et al. Low-cost UAV for high-resolution and large-scale coastal dune change monitoring using photogrammetry[J]. Journal of marine science and engineering,2019,7(3):63.
[5]MANFREDA S,MCCABE M,MILLER P,et al. On the use of unmanned aerial systems for environmental monitoring[J]. Remote sensing,2018,10(4):641.
[6]CAO L,LIU H,FU X,et al. Comparison of UAV LiDAR and digital aerial photogrammetry point clouds for estimating forest structural attributes in subtropical planted forests[J]. Forests,2019,10(2):145.
[7]ROSSI P,MANCINI F,DUBBINI M,et al. Combining nadir and oblique UAV imagery to reconstruct quarry topography:methodology and feasibility analysis[J]. European journal of remote sensing,2017,50(1):211-221.
[8]JAMES M R,ROBSON S,SMITH M W. 3-D uncertainty-based topographic change detection with structure-from-motion photogrammetry:precision maps for ground control and directly georeferenced surveys[J]. Earth surface processes and landforms,2017,42(12):1769-1788.
[9]张纯斌,杨胜天,赵长森,等. 小型消费级无人机地形数据精度验证[J]. 遥感学报,2018,22(1):185-195.
[10]JAMES M R,CHANDLER J H,ELTNER A,et al. Guidelines on the use of structure-from-motion photogrammetry in geomorphic research[J]. Earth surface processes and landforms,2019,44(10):2081-2084.
[11]SMITH M W,VERICAT D. From experimental plots to experimental landscapes:topography,erosion and deposition in sub-humid badlands from structure-from-motion photogrammetry[J]. Earth surface processes and landforms,2015,40(12):1656-1671.
[12]NESBIT P,HUGENHOLTZ C. Enhancing UAV-SfM 3D model accuracy in high-relief landscapes by incorporating oblique images[J]. Remote sensing,2019,11(3):239.
[13]杨国东,王民水. 倾斜摄影测量技术应用及展望[J]. 测绘与空间地理信息,2016,39(1):13-15.
[14]TRONER M,URBAN R,SEIDL J,et al. Photogrammetry using UAV-mounted GNSS RTK:georeferencing strategies without GCPs[J]. Remote sensing,2021,13(7):1336.
[15]HAN X,THOMASSON J A,XIANG Y,et al. Multifunctional ground control points with a wireless network for communication with a UAV[J]. Sensors(Basel Switzerland),2019,19(13):2852.
[16]张光祖,王春,徐燕,等. 像控点布设对无人机小范围非规则区域实景建模精度的影响[J]. 全球定位系统,2020,45(2):60-67.
[17]朱进,丁亚洲,陈攀杰,等. 控制点布设对无人机影像空三精度的影响[J]. 测绘科学,2016,41(5):116-120.
[18]JAMES M R,ROBSON S,D'OLEIRE-OLTMANNS S,et al. Optimising UAV topographic surveys processed with structure-from-motion:ground control quality,quantity and bundle adjustment[J]. Geomorphology,2017,280:51-66.
[19]AGUERA-VEGA F,CARVAJAL-RAMIREZ F,MARTINEZ-CARRICONDO P. Accuracy of digital surface models and orthophotos derived from unmanned aerial vehicle photogrammetry[J]. Journal of surveying engineering,2017,143(2):04016025.
[20]GRAU J,LIANG K,OGILVIE J,et al. Improved accuracy of riparian zone mapping using near ground unmanned aerial vehicle and photogrammetry method[J]. Remote sensing,2021,13(10):1997.
[21]JIMÉNEZ-JIMÉNEZ S I,OJEDA-BUSTAMANTE W,MARCIAL-PABLO M,et al. Digital terrain models generated with low-cost UAV photogrammetry:methodology and accuracy[J]. ISPRS international journal of geo-information,2021,10(5):285.
[22]代文,汤国安,胡光辉,等. 基于无人机摄影测量的地形变化检测方法与小流域输沙模型研究[J]. 地理科学进展,2021,40(9):1570-1580.
[23]EKER R,AYDIN A,HUBL J. Unmanned aerial vehicle(UAV)-based monitoring of a landslide:Gallenzerkogel landslide(Ybbs-Lower Austria)case study[J]. Environmental monitoring and assessment,2018,190(1):28.
[24]GOMEZ-GUTIERREZ A,GONCALVES G R. Surveying coastal cliffs using two UAV platforms(multirotor and fixed-wing)and three different approaches for the estimation of volumetric changes[J]. International journal of remote sensing,2020,41(21):8143-8175.
[25]MARTINEZ-CARRICONDO P,AGUERA-VEGA F,CARVAJAL-RAMIREZ F,et al. Assessment of UAV-photogrammetric mapping accuracy based on variation of ground control points[J]. International journal of applied earth observation and geoinformation,2018,72:1-10.
[26]国家测绘局. 低空数字航空摄影规范(CH/Z 3005—2010)[S]. 北京:测绘出版社,2010.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
收稿日期:2022-07-24.
基金项目:国家自然科学基金项目(42171402、41930102)、安徽高校省级自然科学研究重大项目(KJ2021ZD0130)、江苏省高等学校自然科学研究项目(22KJB170016)、实景地理环境智能科技滁州市“113”产业创新团队、实景地理环境安徽省重点实验室开放课题(2022PGE013)、南京信息工程大学科研启动经费(2022r019).
通讯作者:代文,博士,讲师,研究方向:数字地形分析与实景三维建模. E-mail:wen.dai@nuist.edu.cn
更新日期/Last Update: 2023-06-15